The Tier 2+ Paradox for Mobiles: Solving for Brands and Platforms
Nikhil Dalal
In our previous edition, we highlighted how volatile the Mobiles category is in Online Retail, recording an extreme Seasonality Index Diff of 1.7. This risk is now heavily concentrated in the most crucial segment of the market.
In this edition, we drill down into where this risk is concentrated, proving that the seasonality problem is increasingly a function of the Tier 2+ market, which is also the primary engine for the sector’s growth.
The Shift: Tier 2+ Cities Now Power the Online Mobile Market
Over 50% of GMV now comes from T2+ cities; the share has doubled since 2019, with the T1 and metro cities’ share shrinking by 10% and 17% respectively.
The Pattern: Seasonality Peaks Outside Metro Cities
T2+ cities exhibit the highest seasonality fluctuation. This illustrates a critical duality: T2+ cities are driving the sector’s growth but simultaneously amplifying its operational risk.
Have a question?
Our experts are just a click away.
- T2+ Drives Growth But Amplifies Volatility: Over 50%+ of Mobile Phones GMV now comes from T2+ cities, a share that has doubled since 2019. This indisputably makes T2+ the primary growth engine for the sector.
- Seasonality Peak Concentrated: T2+ markets exhibit the highest seasonality in mobile phones when compared to metros. Furthermore, despite the overall market showing signs of “de-seasonalization,” the volatility remains very high in T2+ cities even in the post-pandemic period. This proves the extreme Sept-Oct peak is fundamentally a sustained T2+ consumer event for the sector.
If you look at T2+ cities’ historical seasonality index, even post-pandemic, the seasonality is still very high in T2+ cities.
Implications for Brands and Platforms
The strategic imperative needs to shift from an overall sector focus to a hyper-localized execution plan that manages the T2+ consumer’s spending cycle.
For Brands: Localizing the Peak-Creation Strategy
- Brands must shift their Peak-Creation strategy to be laser-focused on the T2+ consumer during low-Seasonality Index months (Jan-Apr).
- T2+ Exclusive Affordability: Brands need to move beyond standard nationwide offers. This requires launching T2+ exclusive models, regional sales events tied to local festivals, or deeper affordability schemes (e.g., tailored EMI plans) that directly incentivize the T2+ consumer to purchase a high-ticket item like a Mobile Phone before the Sept-Oct frenzy. This stabilizes the supply chain and revenue in the key growth market.
For Platforms: Geo-Targeting Demand Orchestration
- Platforms must leverage the T2+ growth engine while smoothing out the extreme festive load.
- Decentralizing the Peak: Platforms must use Discount-Driven triggers that are geo-targeted to T2+ cities, actively trying to pull festive season demand forward. This involves using personalized communication and offers to push T2+ consumers to purchase Mobiles in the Jun-Aug window. By distributing T2+ demand across the year, platforms reduce the massive operational strain caused by the single, highly concentrated festive spike.
- Partner with brands for exclusive new launches, special brand and model-specific deals
Summary
The seasonality of the Mobile Phones sector is no longer an overall market challenge; it is a Tier 2+ execution phenomenon. The next phase of online retail growth hinges on a brand’s and platforms’ ability to de-seasonalize their T2+ strategy, converting that highly volatile festive peak demand into consistent, year-round engagement. Brands and Platforms will have to collaborate more to break this T2+ seasonality issue.
The insights have been derived from ‘Benchmarks by Redseer, most trusted insights platform on the Indian internet landscape. Its proprietary consumer internet data allows us to make granular and long-term comparisons that reveal underlying trends and shifts in consumer behaviour.